7 Days Free Trial

for Enterprise Subscriptions

Trusted by 250,000+ Professionals for Continuing Education

Create Your Account 1/2

Already have an account? Log In

First Name

Last Name

Phone

Company Name

Password

Confirm Password

Promo Code

I Accept myCPE Terms and Conditions

You can cancel anytime during your trial period.

Become a Valued Member of myCPE Professionals Community

Trusted by 250,000+ Professionals

"Steven was knowledgeable and thorough…”

Steven was knowledgeable and thorough in his information about the product and what is offered. He was empathetic to my situation. He went above and beyond answering all of my many questions. Excellent service!

Crystal lovejoy

"Great Customer Service”

Great service and very patient as I asked several questions. Steven answered all my questions and helped me make the right decision in my subscription purchase. Thank you.

Lori corry

"It is what it advertised to be”

It is what it advertised to be. Professional quality training and CPE tracking and certificates; systems knows AZ CPA CPE requirements and categories. I've needed help on several occasions and the assistance was quick and effective; however, there were some problems with data entry. The assistance sometimes asks for input, but when I try to type it is dissallowed for some reason. On several occasions I had to close the popup to get it out of my way.

Brian Carey

"Great customer service”

Great customer service. Classes are pertinent. Great value

Steve

1/4

Create Your Free Account

First Name

Last Name

Email Address

Password

Confirm Password

Continue

Already have an account? Log In

Card No.

Card Holder Name

Expiry Date

CVV

Address

Address 2 (Optional)

Zip Code

I Accept myCPE Terms and Conditions

Guaranteed safe & secure checkout

Pay $199

Accounting

7 Costly Mistakes to Avoid When Hiring an Accountant in 2025 (And How to Fix It!)

Amrit Singh
Mar 20, 2025
198

Hiring the right accountant or CPA for your firm is one of the most critical business decisions. Get it right, and you have a high-performing team member driving efficiency, accuracy, and effective compliance management elevating growth. Choose the wrong one, and you are all stuck with missing deadlines, failing compliance, dissatisfied clients, and a lost reputation.

Before you know what to do, know what you must not. How not to hire disasters?

Let’s break down the most common hiring mistakes accounting firms make and how to fix them with a structured hiring approach—including Pre-Built Accounting Assessments to test skills before you hire.

7 Common Hiring Mistakes Accounting Firms Make

1. Skipping a Skill-Based Assessment (Biggest Mistake!)

The Problem: Many firms and HRs rely solely on resumes and interviews to judge a candidate’s ability. But only listing skills “QuickBooks expert, Excel, BI, on their resume—doesn’t mean they are proficient enough to use them efficiently.

The Fix: Use Pre-Built Accounting Assessments to test real-world skills before you hire. These techniques help you to assess the technical expertise, compliance knowledge, and problem-solving skills, of the candidate ensuring that they are actually qualified.

2. Hiring Without Clearly Defining the Role

The Problem: Many accounting firms post vague job descriptions, without clearly defining the job role and expectations, leading to misalignment between expectations and reality. This results in high turnover when the role doesn’t match the hire’s actual strengths.

The Fix: Write clear job descriptions detailing responsibilities, required certifications (CPA, EA, etc.), and expected technical skills. Assess these skills through customized tests before finalizing the hire. 

3. Falling for a Great Interview but Ignoring Real Competency

The Problem: Some candidates interview exceptionally well but lack technical expertise. If you hire based on charm, you risk hiring someone who can’t handle real accounting challenges.

The Fix: Use structured assessments to go beyond interview performance. Pre-built quizzes, Exams, and Knowledge Checks ensure candidates truly understand accounting principles, tax laws, and compliance requirements.

4. Not Testing for Attention to Detail

The Problem: A single accounting error can cost thousands of dollars. If a candidate isn’t detail-oriented, they might overlook crucial numbers, misclassify expenses, or misreport financial statements.

The Fix: Use practical case studies and Include scenario-based questions in hiring assessments. Ask candidates to identify and fix intentional accounting errors in a financial report. There you can test their vigilance and identify the red flag.

5. Ignoring Culture Fit & Team Compatibility

The Problem: A technically strong hire who doesn’t fit your firm’s work culture can cause friction in the team. A bad cultural fit leads to low morale, lack of collaboration, and high turnover.

The Fix: Thoroughly conduct a behavioral assessment alongside technical tests. Ask questions and assess their capabilities to handle deadlines, teamwork, and client interactions, if they are the right ones to fit into your work culture.

6. Overlooking Compliance & Fraud Risks

The Problem: Hiring an accountant without testing their ethics or regulatory knowledge can expose your firm to compliance violations and even fraud risks.

The Fix: Use CPA & Tax Compliance Assessments to evaluate a candidate’s understanding of GAAP, IRS regulations, and industry ethics. Don’t assume they know—verify it.

7. Skipping Post-Hire Assessments & Continuous Learning

The Problem: Many firms stop evaluating employees after hiring, leading to skill gaps and outdated knowledge.

The Fix: Continuing Education is very crucial to keep your team up to date with the late development and never fall behind. A Teams L&D plan can help you to seamlessly manage the professional development of your whole team members all while meeting their CPE compliances.

Our Team Subscription Plan includes:

Course Quizzes & Final Exams – Ensure employees grasp key accounting topics.
Custom Quiz Builder – Create internal assessments for firm-specific training.
Knowledge Checks & Practice Exams – Help employees stay sharp and up to date.
Analytics on Assessments – Track team performance, spot weaknesses, and improve training.

Hiring the right accountant is easier with skill-based hiring tools!

Take the Guesswork Out of Hiring

Bad hires are costly. Why take chances? Make smarter hiring decisions with Pre-Built Accounting Assessments available in our Plus & Premium Plans.

Test real skills before you hire.
Verify compliance knowledge.
Reduce turnover & improve hiring accuracy.

Conclusion Hiring Smart Saves, You Money & Stress

If you’re still stuck in the same old hiring process based on resumes and gut feeling, it’s time to evolve. Adopt Structured hiring + skill-based assessments = fewer mistakes, better hires, and a stronger team of accountants.

Amrit Singh

Amrit has over six years of experience in continuing education, focusing on CPE for Accounting, Tax, Finance, HR, Payroll, and Technology in the US, Canada, and UK. Amrit simplifies compliance, creates easy-to-use solutions, and helps professionals stay updated while saving time on their education requirements

Table of Contents