The WFH Dilemma: Why Complete Remote Work May Not Be Ideal for Accounting Firms

Remote working has become much more popular due to recent events, especially Covid-19. People globally are shifting towards this approach, prompting many businesses, including accounting firms, to reconsider their operational models. It is not wrong to say that working from Home (WFH) brings many advantages, but if we add challenges to this paradigm, then that is also true. In this blog, we explore those challenges and suggest that accounting firms be cautious when implementing a full WFH policy. Moreover, we will shed light on alternative approaches that balance flexibility with productivity and security.   

The Indian Cultural Context

Fully remote work in an Indian cultural context presents unique challenges, as both firms and employees often value socio-professional relationships that are more easily nurtured in a traditional office environment. A shared physical space promotes collaboration, learning, and potentially higher productivity while also helping to develop a strong, cohesive company culture. However, establishing an office in cities like Mumbai can be costly, potentially reducing the financial benefits of setting up operations in India. Conversely, a fully remote setup greatly broadens your talent pool and offers the flexibility that many employees find attractive, making your company stand out in a competitive job market. 

The Challenges of Complete WFH  

1. Security and Data Privacy:

There are heightened concerns about data security and privacy when employees access company systems from home, especially if they are using personal devices or unsecured networks. You don’t want your staff to work from “Starbucks in India.” Ensuring compliance with various regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA) can be more challenging in a remote work environment.  

Key concerns include: 

  • Unsecured home networks 
  • Use of personal devices for work purposes 
  • Difficulty in ensuring compliance with regulations like GDPR and HIPAA 
  • Increased vulnerability to cyber attacks 

2. Moonlighting and Freelancing:

Employees might engage in work for competitors, smaller firms, or even start their own ventures while taking on second assignments. This practice, often illegal, can significantly hamper productivity and create substantial conflicts of interest, jeopardizing firms' interests in a big way. 

Potential consequences include: 

  • Reduced productivity in the primary job 
  • Conflicts of interest, especially if working for competitors 
  • Breach of contractual obligations and confidentiality agreements 
  • Intellectual property concerns   

3. Productivity and Burnout: 

Employees working from home may struggle to maintain a clear boundary between work and personal life, leading to overwork and the lack of separation between work and home life, which can also contribute to stress and mental health issues over time. When employees divide their time and energy between multiple jobs, their productivity in their primary job can suffer.   

The lack of clear boundaries between work and personal life can lead to: 

  • Overwork and increased stress levels 
  • Difficulty in "switching off" from work mode 
  • Reduced efficiency due to home distractions 
  • Potential for mental health issues over time 
  • Missed Deadlines 
  • Lower Quality Works 

4. Tracking and Accountability:

There are concerns about how to effectively monitor and measure employee productivity when working remotely. It can be challenging to ensure that employees are maintaining the same level of output as they would in an office environment. Home environments can be filled with distractions, which may impact an employee's ability to focus and work efficiently.  

Accounting firms may struggle with: 

  • Measuring output effectively 
  • Ensuring consistent work quality 
  • Managing deadlines and project timelines 
  • Maintaining team cohesion and collaboration  

While various digital tools exist to track remote work, they often cannot fully replicate the oversight and spontaneous interactions that occur in an office environment.   

5. Technological and Infrastructure Challenges: 

Not all employees may have access to the necessary technology or a stable internet connection at home, which could impact their ability to perform their jobs effectively. Providing IT support remotely can be more complex and time-consuming.  

Issues may include:  

  • Unreliable internet connections 
  • Lack of appropriate hardware or software 
  • Difficulty in providing remote IT support 
  • Inconsistent power supply in some areas 

These challenges can lead to disruptions in work, missed meetings, and overall reduced efficiency.   

6. Impact on Company Culture: 

The lack of physical interaction can erode the company culture, making it harder to maintain a sense of belonging and shared values among employees. Keeping employees engaged and connected with the company's mission and values is more difficult when they are not physically present. 

It can lead to: 

  • Reduced sense of belonging among employees 
  • Difficulty in transmitting company values and mission 
  • Challenges in onboarding and integrating new employees 
  • Decreased employee engagement and loyalty    

The Case for a Hybrid Approach

Considering the challenges given above, a complete WFH model may not be the best solution for accounting firms in India. To maintain the balance, a hybrid approach can be suggested. Hybrid working combines in-office work with remote options, which could offer a more balanced solution.   

Benefits of a hybrid model include: 

  • Maintaining face-to-face interactions and collaboration 
  • Easier monitoring of work and productivity 
  • Enhanced data security through controlled office environments 
  • Preservation of company culture and employee engagement 
  • Flexibility for employees, improving job satisfaction   

Our Recommendation

Based on the challenges outlined and the unique needs of accounting firms, we recommend prioritizing a full-time office work setup. However, if this isn't feasible, a hybrid working model is the next best option. This could involve: 

  • Allowing employees to work from home during the latter part of the day 
  • Implementing 1-2 remote workdays per week 
  • Flexible start times to accommodate commuting challenges 

This approach helps maintain productivity, develops a balanced work environment, and addresses many of the concerns associated with complete WFH.  

Special Considerations for High-Traffic Cities: In cities like Mumbai and Bangalore, where commuting can take 1 to 3 hours on average, a more flexible approach might be necessary. For these locations, we recommend: 

  • Having employees come into the office at least once a week 
  • Focusing on hiring highly experienced professionals (e.g., directors or senior managers from Big Four or top 20 accounting firms) for remote positions 
  • Implementing strict security protocols for remote work 
  • Regular virtual team-building activities to maintain company culture   

MYCPE ONE as Your Partner: As you navigate these challenges, partnering with a company like MYCPE ONE can provide significant advantages: 

  • Access to a broad talent pool across 18 cities in India and the Philippines 
  • Robust cybersecurity measures implemented by our IT team 
  • Experience in managing hybrid and remote work models 
  • Support in maintaining productivity and work quality in various setups   

Final Thoughts 

The allure of the complete WFH may be a strong option, especially in the wake of the latest global trends. However, it is crucial for accounting firms to consider the potential pitfalls carefully and clearly. The unique challenges posed by data security, productivity concerns, and the importance of company culture in the Indian context make a complete WFH model less than ideal.  

A thoughtful approach like a hybrid setup offers the best of both worlds. This will benefit both firms and employees on the same level. As the business landscape continues to evolve, it is necessary for accounting firms to be adaptable. By carefully considering the pros and cons of different work models and partnering with experienced providers like MYCPE ONE, firms can create a work environment that enhances productivity, ensures security, and fosters a strong, positive company culture. In doing so, they'll be well-positioned to meet the challenges of the future while delivering the high-quality service that clients expect. 

Shawn Parikh

Shawn Parikh

Co-Founder & CEO

Shawn Parikh is the CEO and Co-Founder of MYCPE ONE. A Chartered Accountant by qualification, he has over 15 years of experience of being a problem solver for small to mid-size firms and over time he has given consultation to thousands of CPAs, accountants and tax pros. Shawn has always been a big believer and advocate of social enterprises and small accounting firms & businesses. He consults and speaks on several topics ranging from Building Remote Team - Remote Working, Offshore Staffing, strategic planning, Scalability of Accounting Practice, cloud accounting, practice management, LinkedIn marketing, etc.

Must Read Blogs